The Golf Draft - Must-Have Thanksgiving Foods

Thanksgiving is about family, fellowship, football, and giving thanks. But let's be honest: the food is doing a lot of the heavy lifting.

For this edition of The Golf Draft, Jonathan and Robby stepped away from their usual golf-related topics and tackled something that might be even more divisive: drafting the must-have foods for Thanksgiving dinner.

The rules were simple. Five picks each. Build the ultimate Thanksgiving menu. No pressure, but the reputation of your entire holiday meal is on the line.

Let's take a look at the teams.

The Draft

Robby's Team

  1. Turkey

  2. Corn Casserole

  3. Apple Pie

  4. Sweet Potatoes

  5. Brussels Sprouts

Jonathan's Team

  1. Ham

  2. Mashed Potatoes

  3. Green Beans

  4. Cool Whip

  5. Charcuterie Board

Team-by-Team Analysis

Robby's Team

1. Turkey — A

You can't start a Thanksgiving food draft with anything other than turkey. It's the centerpiece. It's the tradition. It's the reason there's a special dinner in the first place. Robby didn't overthink this one, and he shouldn't have.

The only knock? Turkey can be a little hit or miss depending on who's cooking it. A dry turkey can ruin an otherwise great meal. But when it's done right, there's no better first-round pick.

2. Corn Casserole — A+

This is where Robby starts to separate himself from the competition. Corn casserole is one of those dishes that quietly becomes a fan favorite every Thanksgiving. It's sweet, savory, soft, and somehow manages to go with just about everything on the plate.

It's not always the first thing people mention when talking about Thanksgiving, but it's often one of the first things to disappear. Excellent value with the second pick.

3. Apple Pie — A

A strong dessert pick. Apple pie is a Thanksgiving classic, and Robby made sure his team wouldn't be finishing dinner without something sweet.

It's familiar, dependable, and best served warm. The only concern is that Jonathan drafted Cool Whip, which could create an interesting situation where Robby has the pie and Jonathan has the topping. A little cross-team cooperation might be necessary.

4. Sweet Potatoes — B+

Sweet potatoes are a Thanksgiving staple, and they bring something different to the plate. Whether they're mashed, roasted, topped with brown sugar, or covered in marshmallows, there's a lot to like.

The challenge is that sweet potatoes can be a little polarizing depending on how they're prepared. Still, Robby gets credit for adding another traditional side that rounds out his menu.

5. Brussels Sprouts — B

This is a bold final pick. Brussels sprouts have come a long way from the days when they were the vegetable everyone tried to avoid. Roasted properly, with a little seasoning and maybe some bacon, they're a legitimate Thanksgiving side.

But let's not pretend this is a universally loved pick. Some people are excited to see Brussels sprouts on the table. Others are wondering why we're making them eat vegetables on a holiday.

A respectable fifth-round selection, but probably not the pick that wins the draft.

Overall Grade: A-

Robby built a team with a clear identity: traditional Thanksgiving food with a few strong supporting players. Turkey anchors the menu, corn casserole is a tremendous side, and apple pie gives him a reliable finish.

The biggest weakness is the absence of mashed potatoes and gravy. That's a pretty significant hole in the lineup.

Jonathan's Team

1. Ham — A-

Jonathan opens with ham, and while it's not the traditional first pick for a Thanksgiving draft, it's a strong choice. A properly cooked ham brings a salty, savory flavor that gives the table another option beyond turkey.

It's also a little more forgiving than turkey when it comes to leftovers. Jonathan gets credit for going against the grain, although passing on turkey is a risky way to start this draft.

2. Mashed Potatoes — A+

Now we're talking. Mashed potatoes might be the most important side dish on the entire Thanksgiving table. They're comforting, dependable, and absolutely essential when gravy is involved.

This is a fantastic second-round pick and arguably the best side dish selected in the entire draft. The only question is how Jonathan plans to eat them without gravy, which somehow went undrafted.

3. Green Beans — B

A solid, responsible pick. Green beans bring some balance to a meal that otherwise tends to involve a lot of butter, sugar, and carbs.

They're not necessarily the most exciting dish on the table, but they have a place. Green bean casserole would have given this pick a little more personality, but we'll give Jonathan credit for making sure his team has a vegetable.

4. Cool Whip — C+

Well, this is where things get interesting.

Cool Whip is not technically a Thanksgiving dish. It's a supporting player. It needs a partner. It needs a purpose. And, as it turns out, Jonathan may have drafted it specifically to pair with Robby's apple pie.

It's a fun pick, but taking Cool Whip in the fourth round when there are still plenty of actual Thanksgiving dishes available is a questionable decision. At least Jonathan won't have to worry about dessert being dry.

5. Charcuterie Board — B+

This is a sneaky-good pick, even if it feels a little out of place in a traditional Thanksgiving food draft.

A charcuterie board is perfect for the hours leading up to dinner. It's something for people to snack on while the turkey finishes cooking, the football games are on, and everyone asks how much longer until the food is ready.

The downside is that it's not really part of the Thanksgiving dinner itself. But if we're drafting the entire Thanksgiving food experience, Jonathan gets credit for thinking beyond the main meal.

Overall Grade: B+

Jonathan has some excellent picks. Ham is a strong alternative to turkey, mashed potatoes are a home run, and the charcuterie board gives his team a nice pre-dinner advantage.

But Cool Whip in the fourth round is going to be difficult to explain. And like Robby, Jonathan somehow forgot to draft gravy.

The Verdict: Who Won the Thanksgiving Draft?

Winner: Robby

This was closer than it might look at first glance.

Jonathan probably landed the best individual side dish with mashed potatoes, and his charcuterie board is a great addition to the overall Thanksgiving experience. But Robby's team has a little more balance and a stronger connection to the traditional Thanksgiving meal.

Turkey is the most important pick in the draft, corn casserole is an outstanding second-round selection, and apple pie gives him a legitimate dessert option.

Jonathan's team has some real strengths, but Cool Whip as a standalone pick is a tough one to overcome. It's like drafting a golf cart instead of another golfer. Useful? Absolutely. But does it belong in the starting lineup?

Robby takes this one, but Jonathan has enough quality on his roster to make it interesting.

The Golf Draft Awards

Best Pick: Mashed Potatoes — Jonathan

A+ pick. No explanation needed. If mashed potatoes aren't on your Thanksgiving table, we need to have a conversation.

Best Value Pick: Corn Casserole — Robby

A tremendous second-round selection. It's one of those dishes that doesn't always get the recognition it deserves but is almost always a crowd favorite.

Most Controversial Pick: Cool Whip — Jonathan

We're still trying to figure out whether this is a legitimate Thanksgiving food or simply a condiment that Jonathan decided deserved its own roster spot.

Best Supporting Player: Charcuterie Board — Jonathan

It might not belong on the dinner plate, but it's going to be doing some serious work before dinner. A smart pick for the full Thanksgiving experience.

Most Likely to Be Left on the Plate: Brussels Sprouts — Robby

We respect the pick. We appreciate the effort to include a vegetable. But there's a reason these things tend to get pushed around the plate by kids and adults alike.

Biggest Draft Mistake: Both teams passing on stuffing and gravy.

Somebody needed to take responsibility here. Stuffing and gravy are two of the most important foods on the Thanksgiving table, and somehow neither made it onto either roster. That's a major oversight.

The Foods Left on the Board

The biggest takeaway from this draft might be what wasn't selected.

Stuffing. Gravy. Dinner rolls. Cranberry sauce. Macaroni and cheese. Pecan pie. Pumpkin pie.

There are some legitimate first-round talents sitting on the sidelines. In fact, you could make a pretty convincing argument that stuffing and gravy should have been selected before several of the foods that actually made the cut.

Maybe we need a second draft.

Final Thoughts

Thanksgiving food is personal. Everybody has a favorite dish, everybody has something they refuse to eat, and everybody seems to think their family's version of a particular recipe is the only correct one.

That's what makes this draft fun. There's no perfect menu, but there are definitely some questionable decisions.

So we'll leave it to you: Who built the better Thanksgiving table? Robby or Jonathan? And more importantly, what food was the biggest omission from this draft?

Back to blog